A Look at the Numbers
Although violence against women certainly isn’t the only form of domestic violence, most cases do target women as the victim. That being said, statistically speaking, violence against the aged is almost as common as violence against women—so much so that most states (including California) recognize elder abuse as a separate category of crime. Here in the U.S., approximately one in five seniors will experience some form of abuse (compared to one in four women), the vast majority of which will never be reported. Among those cases of elder abuse, at least two-thirds of them are committed by a family member (e.g., a child or spouse). By these numbers, two-thirds of the incidents of elder abuse also technically classify as acts of domestic violence.
Understanding Elder Abuse versus Domestic Violence
While there is definitely some overlap between elder abuse and domestic violence, there are some semantic differences between them. So let’s examine the differences so we can see more clearly where they overlap.
Domestic violence is essentially defined as an abusive act committed by a person against a spouse, relative, or other current or former member of their household. The majority of these crimes occur between current or former spouses or romantic/sexual partners (also known as intimate partner violence), but domestic violence can also include violent acts against children, sibling, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews, grandparents, and even roommates—basically any member of the household, plus any ex-partners who might no longer live in the home.
Elder abuse is defined in California as an abusive act committed against someone who is age 65 or older. As with domestic violence, elder abuse encompasses numerous forms of abuse besides those that involve physical contact. Specifically, elder abuse can be:
- Physical abuse (assaulting and/or inflicting injury);
- Sexual abuse;
- Emotional abuse (e.g., ridicule, mockery, verbal abuse, isolation/control);
- Neglect/endangerment (depriving an elderly person of basic needs, either willfully or incidentally); and/or
- Financial abuse (stealing from and/or defrauding an elderly person).
The main difference between elder and domestic abuse is that elder abuse is classified solely by the age of the victim, while domestic abuse is defined by the relationship between the victim and the accused. There is obviously plenty of room for overlap—as mentioned earlier, the perpetrator in most elder abuse cases also happens to be a family member—but not all acts of elder abuse are considered domestic violence. Basically, any person who assaults or abuses a senior citizen, related or not, is committing elder abuse. That person could be a caregiver, a nursing home attendant, a stranger on the street, or even a scam artist who targets the elderly.
Will You Be Charged with Domestic Violence or Elder Abuse?
In California, both domestic violence and elder abuse may be charged as either misdemeanors or felonies—and both types of crimes generally carry stiffer penalties than other types of violence or assault. If the incident that resulted in your arrest classifies as both domestic violence and elder abuse, you could face multiple charges in both categories. However, each specific charge will likely occur under one of those two categories—not both. For example, if you are accused of both striking your grandmother and making harassing phone calls to her, prosecutors might choose to charge the phone harassment as domestic violence while the physical assault would be charged as elder abuse. But you wouldn’t necessarily face domestic violence and elder abuse charges stacked on top of each other just for the alleged assault, nor would your sentence be doubled if you were convicted.
Having said all that, when there is overlap between domestic violence and elder abuse, prosecutors will usually look at several factors when deciding how to charge you, including the following:
- The specific circumstances of the alleged incident. They will investigate the case thoroughly to determine which elements should be charged in which category.
- If the alleged action falls into one category more clearly than the other. (For example, stalking is defined more clearly as a form of domestic violence than as elder abuse.)
- Which charge has the highest likelihood of conviction. If, for some reason, the prosecution feels the jury is more likely to convict you on an elder abuse charge than a domestic violence one, they will usually go with elder abuse.
- Which charge carries the stiffest penalty. (If, for example, the prosecution can only justify charging you with a misdemeanor for DV but a felony for elder abuse, they might choose elder abuse—especially if they feel they have the evidence to prove the claim.)
What It Means for You
Domestic violence against senior citizens can be a legally complicated mess. For instance, if you have an unfortunate disagreement with an older family member that escalates out of control, that incident may now be entangled in the intersection between domestic violence and elder abuse, and you could be facing a variety of complex charges as a result. In such cases, it’s more essential than ever to have experienced legal counsel to guide you through the process and help you develop a strong defense. If you are facing domestic violence charges against an elderly person in southern California, we can help. Call our office today for a free case evaluation.